• 0Shopping Cart
Collaroy Cromer Strikers Fooball Academy
  • Home
  • Academy information
    • Academy Staff
  • Programs
    • Group Training
      • Boys Group Training Term 1
      • Boys Group Training Term 2
      • Girls Group Training Term 1
      • Girls Group Training Term 2
    • 1on1 Coaching
    • Team Training
    • Goalkeeper Training
    • School Holiday Camp
  • Sponsers
  • Club Website
  • Contact
  • Menu Menu

Artificial grass vs natural grass – Part 7

28/06/2020/in The more you know /by Liam Bonney

Another aspect that must be considered when undertaking such large projects in the community is the environmental impacts a project might have. Natural grass fields as I mentioned above do require fertilizing and, in some cases, this can lead to run off into local creeks. This runoff then gets into the water systems and can add to the pollution that then goes into the ocean. The grass clippings as well if not properly disposed of may transport weeds that are in the ground via vegetative propagation. These are the two main environmental impacts of the maintenance of natural grass. If natural grass was simply left by itself then it really would not have an impact on the environment. Eventually it would grow wild and effectively create a habitat for flora and fauna to grow.

Artificial grass on the other hand can have a significant impact on the environment. Firstly, the construction of the field completely changes the soil composition and removes all the natural grass that can be a habitat for small insects, lizards which then provide food for birds and so on. On top of that, runoff from the construction process depending on where it occurs may end up in the creek or river systems. This can then cause algae blooms and promote the growth of weeds and invasive species. Furthermore, if it gets into the ocean it creates the same issues as fertilizers. Grass although small also contributes to the reduction of pollution through the process of photosynthesis.

There are also concerns to do with the rubber pellets. There are already many cases of animals mistaking small bits of manmade materials such as plastic as food. Once they are ingested animals may become sick and may even die as a result. This concern is especially relevant to the existing artificial field at Melwood Oval and the proposed artificial grass fields to go in at Millers Reserve. Both sites have creeks bordering the oval. There have been concerns raised by community members that the rubber pellets and runoff from the fields will enter the water system and animals may mistake these as food.

 

https://ccstrikersfc.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/93622223_3245112565556359_4723169990608420864_n_3245112562223026.jpg 0 0 Liam Bonney https://ccstrikersfc.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/93622223_3245112565556359_4723169990608420864_n_3245112562223026.jpg Liam Bonney2020-06-28 14:32:382019-11-15 09:22:30Artificial grass vs natural grass – Part 7

Artificial grass vs natural grass – Part 6

21/06/2020/in The more you know /by Liam Bonney

One of the main reasons for the conversion of playing fields from natural grass to artificial grass is cost effectiveness. Natural grass fields require a large amount of maintenance to keep in a good condition. This can seem like a futile expense when someone sees the state of the fields after the football season. The fields need to be watered, fertilized, weed sprayed, aerated, relayed and even completely resurfaced most of which also includes labor. All of this adds up especially when you consider how many grounds the council must manage. This is even more important from a water perspective especially since in Australia we have the ever-present threat of drought.

Artificial fields require a significant outlay for the initial construction but after that they barely require any maintenance whatsoever. The only maintenance that I have observed on the artificial fields is the occasional re-distribution of the rubber pellets and re-surfacing of the penalty spot. This then means that the artificial fields are long-term investments. It should mean that in the long run costs are significantly reduced. This is the main benefit of having artificial surfaces and is often the main justification for them.

I am 100% for them in this instance I do have concerns over it though. I am only for it if the cost of maintaining the fields is adjusted appropriately. Currently the council charges the association who then charges the clubs for the maintenance of the fields. Personally, I do not think this is right. The council would have to maintain the fields regardless if people were playing sport on them or not. Personally, I think that the clubs should only pay for the maintenance that I has to take place as a result of football occurring. Such as the relaying of turf. As I said before I am all for it, as long as the savings is passed on down through to the residents of area and/or the players.

 

https://ccstrikersfc.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/93622223_3245112565556359_4723169990608420864_n_3245112562223026.jpg 0 0 Liam Bonney https://ccstrikersfc.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/93622223_3245112565556359_4723169990608420864_n_3245112562223026.jpg Liam Bonney2020-06-21 14:29:042019-11-15 09:22:37Artificial grass vs natural grass – Part 6

Artificial grass vs natural grass – Part 5

14/06/2020/in The more you know /by Liam Bonney

There are also social implications of the two different types of field surfaces. Natural Grass fields are accessible and usable by anyone who wants to use them. Whether that be for playing football or whether that is for a picnic or walking the dog.

However, artificial grass fields are not as accessible for everyone. You can play most sports on them, Fields around here also host cricket, AFL and football. But it wouldn’t be recommended to play either rugby codes on them, too much of the sport is played on the ground. I had one friend who said they played on an artificial field specifically made for rugby and within in 5 minutes most players were cut up by the abrasive surface and sent to the blood bin.

Cricket pitches are placed in between synthetic fields if there is more than two. If there is only one field, patches of artificial grass are placed over the hard-synthetic cricket pitches to make it safe to play football on. So, synthetic pitches can be compatible with artificial grass fields, but turf cricket pitches are not. At least I have not seen the two crossed over. I think it could be done, but you would need either a drop-in pitch, or enough space between two pitches to keep the turf pitch throughout winter. Anyway the point is that artificial football fields mean that either turf pitches are removed or they must be converted to synthetic pitches.

They also limit the amount of leisure activities that can take place. You cannot walk your dog on artificial fields for instance. This is largely a concern over dog poo being left on the field and ruining the playing surface. But there are other concerns for the dogs. The rubber pellets could potentially be ingested through either their mouths or their noses which could cause significant health issues. I am sure they are non-toxic but that doesn’t mean they couldn’t cause blockages.  The pellets would also get tangled and trapped in the hair of the dogs. Anyone who has ever played on artificial grass even just once will know that the rubber pellets get in everywhere, imagine what it would be like for a dog.

It also would not the most comfortable thing to have a picnic on, it would be flat, but also very hot. The rubber pellet would also get in everything. I will say though the likely hood of ants invading your food would be significantly reduced so there are pros and cons to this.

 

https://ccstrikersfc.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/93622223_3245112565556359_4723169990608420864_n_3245112562223026.jpg 0 0 Liam Bonney https://ccstrikersfc.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/93622223_3245112565556359_4723169990608420864_n_3245112562223026.jpg Liam Bonney2020-06-14 14:27:142019-11-15 09:22:47Artificial grass vs natural grass – Part 5

Artificial grass vs natural grass – Part 4

07/06/2020/in The more you know /by Liam Bonney

Injuries. Injuries are apart of football and indeed any sport. However, in recent years artificial grass surfaces have come under intense scrutiny for potentially causing more injuries than natural grass surfaces. This may be down to equipment as well as the surface but ill expand on this a little later. Natural grass has a natural give in it when you push your studs into the ground or when you fall. This means that there may be a very slight reduction in grip but at the same time this is not a bad thing. As an example, if a players foot is in the ground and they get tackled, you wont the boot to be able to dislodge from the ground or at the very least give way a little to be able to absorb the impact. Otherwise what can end up happening is the boot and ankle stay in one position whilst your body goes in another. Not ideal.

Firm ground boots tend to have either medium length conical studs or blades. The theory is that both provide to much grip on artificial pitches and therefore lead to more injuries. Whether they be non-contact or contact related. In response to this, boot makers have now started producing boots specifically for artificial grass fields. These often include shorter, rounded and softer studs so that they do not offer as much traction and are therefore safer. That’s not to say that you will not get injured but the chance of it and perhaps the severity of it may be reduced.

In terms of minor cuts and bruises, they tend to happen on both surfaces. The natural grass surfaces are relatively forgiving at the start of the season when they have grass on them. However, once the grass and top layer of soil are gone then its almost like sliding on concrete. Artificial Grass is harsh and usually after sliding on it once or twice you are likely to be grazed up.

 

https://ccstrikersfc.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/93622223_3245112565556359_4723169990608420864_n_3245112562223026.jpg 0 0 Liam Bonney https://ccstrikersfc.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/93622223_3245112565556359_4723169990608420864_n_3245112562223026.jpg Liam Bonney2020-06-07 14:22:432019-11-15 09:22:57Artificial grass vs natural grass – Part 4

Categories

  • Benefits of Football
  • Changes to the game
  • Tactics of modern football
  • The Direction of Football in Australia
  • The more you know
  • Uncategorized

Archives

  • April 2021
  • March 2021
  • February 2021
  • January 2021
  • December 2020
  • November 2020
  • October 2020
  • September 2020
  • August 2020
  • July 2020
  • June 2020
  • May 2020
  • April 2020
  • March 2020
  • February 2020
  • January 2020
  • December 2019
  • November 2019
  • October 2019
  • September 2019

Links:

Contact
Privacy
Terms

Login

© Collaroy Cromer Strikers Football Club   |   All rights reserved
Site by Ripple Marketing

Scroll to top